In New Zealand the Minister of Safety is in hot water for musing about the mandatory helmet law discouraging people from cycling. As we know that more cyclists makes cycling safer and more comfortable (the so-called safety in numbers principle), it is fair for him to muse, but there is little chance of the current law being changed.
I am thankful that we don't have mandatory helmet legislation here.
For the news, you can visit:
http://www.stuff.co.nz/thepress/4737003a24035.html
http://www.stuff.co.nz/thepress/4736254a24035.html
http://www.voxy.co.nz/politics/cycle-helmet-safety-regulations-questione...
http://www.radionz.co.nz/news/stories/2008/10/23/12437a3f0bd7
Comments
Kevin Love (not verified)
Vigilance is necessary here also
Thu, 11/13/2008 - 06:01Every so often there is a push in the Ontario legislature for similar legislation here. See, for example,
http://www.toronto.ca/cycling/reports.htm
Education of politicians is necessary. We need to continue to point out, politely and respectfully, that mandatory helmet laws actually result in more deaths and serious injuries by discouraging cycling.
Point out the Australian experience and all the deaths that happened there with a mandatory helmet law. Point out that Holland is the safest place in the world to cycle, and almost nobody wears a helmet there. Point out that car pollution kills 440 people in Toronto every year, and injures 1,700 so seriously that they have to be hospitalized.
Make it clear that a mandatory bicycle helmet law in Ontario will result in a large number of people being killed or seriously injured. And that this carnage will be on their conscience.
Peter (not verified)
Helmets are for everyone / every cyclist
Sun, 01/25/2009 - 22:53I live in Cambridge, Ontario. In 1995, I was 7 1/2 years old. I was hit by a car while riding a bicycle. I was not wearing a helmet. I now suffer from a severe brain injury. the helmet law was passed in 1995 for cyclists 18 and under to wear a helmet. Adults have the choice if they would like to wear a helmet or not. I disagree a bit because I think that all cyclists, no matter what age should wear a helmet, even Adults. It is for safety. I am 31 years old now, and I wear a helmet while biking. I don't want another brain injury. One time a year or two ago, I saw a young boy riding his bicycle on the sidewalk with his helmet on the handle bar of the bike, not on his head. He rode across the street which was a bit busy. I though that he would get hit, but he didn't which was good. There was a police car nearby that was stopped at a red light, he saw this, and did nothing. I went to the police station later, and told them about what I saw, and they told me this "Well, what would you like us to do?. I told them that they can stop the boy and talk to him, and tell him why it is important to wear a helmet on the head, and not on the handle bars. They told me, "We can't really do that". That upset me, because there is a law about cyclists under the age of 18 who are required to wear a helmet on their head while riding a bicycle, and the police do nothing? The police are supposed to serve and protect. They did not do this in this case. My thought on the law is still every cyclist no matter what age should wear a helmet on their head, starting from when they start to ride a tricycle when they are very young to when they are elderly riding two wheel bikes. If we can teach the young children to wear a helmet, while riding their bicycle, or even tricycle, and the importance of it, then maybe when they are older, and over the age of 18, they might still wear helmets. However, it is not just the schools that should be teaching this, because they are teaching this, but it is also the parents thst should be teaching this. I see sometimes parents riding a bicycle with their children. The children sometimes have a helmet on their head, and the parents sometimes do not. What kind of example and message does this send the children, I think to my self. In other cases I do see some parents riding a bicycle with their children, and both parents and children are wearing helmets, which is very good, and sets a very good example and message. In my last words of thought, helmets are for every one, every cyclist, every age. I think helmets should be also introduced in the daycare's/childcare's, so the children can wear a helmet while riding the tricycles there. Even though there is no traffic of cars there, they do fall off them sometimes. Accidents do happen. Anyways, that's all for now, but thank you very much for your time. I hope that this message, a long message, can be helpful.
Peter (not verified)
Another thing I forgot to mention
Sun, 01/25/2009 - 23:09Hello it's me again, I just forgot to mention another thing about the helmet law. It should be more and better enforced by the police to protect everyone. There is no excuse to not protect. Thank you again.
Peter (not verified)
1985
Thu, 01/29/2009 - 14:43I made a little mistake. It wasn't 1995 that I was hit. It was 1985. I was 7 1/2 years old.
I am now 31 years old.
The EnigManiac
Why...
Thu, 01/29/2009 - 17:16...is it that so many pro-helmet cyclists feel the need to preach their mantra and try to have every cyclist become like them? It's as bad as bible-thumpers trying to get me into their church.
It's unfortunate you had a bike accident when you were 7 and suffered a brain injury. I, too, had many a tumble from my bikes when I was a kid and suffered lots of scrapes, cuts, bruises and sprains, but fortunately no broken bones or serious head injuries. It's part of growing up. But because there is a stronger liklihood of a serious head injury among children, there is a law in place and I support it. I insist my 15 year-old son wears his helmet as a result, even though he is a better cyclist than 90% of the adults I see on the road. He was brushed by an SUV 5 years ago and hit his helmeted head on the road and I remind him of that every so often, if only to reinforce that he could have had a serious injury had it not been for the helmet.
But I am 46 and have been riding since I was very young. I ride in dense, downtown traffic year-round---almost daily---and have been doing so for more than 25 years. I've had thousands of close calls, but not one collision nor one fall. I don't like anything on my head at all as they all cause me to sweat profusely and it makes me both uncomfortable and miserable. With sweat flowing into my eyes, it also endangers me as my sight is impaired. I don't wear a helmet and I won't wear a helmet, though I have tried on a few occasions and hated it. It's not about looks for me---I'm pretty ugly as it is and a helmet won't make a difference either way (LOL).
But I also don't go around telling everyone NOT to wear a helmet or that they must ride recumbents because they are better for your body or that they need to use 3 lights in the front and 3 in the back like I do because it's safer. How other adults ride is their business and I respect their right to choose how and what they ride and how and what they wear. It has no bearing on me as a cyclist or a person.
Please, continue wearing a helmet all you like, but leave the proselytizing at the door. It's offensive, arrogant and disrespectful. Like Hank Williams sang years ago, 'mind your own business, 'cause if you mind your own business then you won't be minding mine.'